[Consequences of tibiotalar arthrodesis on the foot. A retrospective study of 36 cases with 8.5 years of followup]


Published online: Mar 27 1999

H Ben Amor, S Kallel, S Karray, F Saadaoui, M Zouari, T Litaiem, and M Douik.

Institut National d'Orthopédie M. T. Kassab, La Manouba, Tunisie.

Abstract

The authors report the results of a retrospective study of 36 cases of tibiotalar arthrodesis performed in 22 men and 14 women with an average age of 32 years. All patients were reviewed with an average of 8.5 years follow-up. The predominating etiologies were ankle osteoarthritis (15 cases) and neurologic deformities of the foot (13 cases). Arthrodesis was performed using the Meary technique in 60% of cases, using the Charnley technique in 20% and the Crawford-Adams technique or with clamps in the other cases. Fusion was obtained in 97% of cases. Long-term results were assessed using Duquennoy et al.'s scoring system. They were very good or good in 58% of cases, fair in 31% and poor in 11%. The study of distal repercussions of tibiotalar arthrodesis shows progressive deterioration of the subtalar joint in 70% of cases and appearance or increase of degenerative changes in 75% of cases. The final results of the procedure depend on this deterioration; the latter is related with the arthrodesis position. Midtalar joint is a compensation joint showing hypermobility in 40% of cases. Degenerative changes were limited and asymptomatic in 80% of cases. Based on the findings in this study and on the literature, we conclude that the foot should be fixed at 90 degrees or with less than 5 degrees of equinus, with 5 degrees of valgus and 10 to 15 degrees of external rotation.