Is there any difference between the biomechanical strengths of the current fixation techniques for comminuted distal patellar fractures? (Comparison of distal patella fracture fixation techniques)

Abstract

In this biomechanical study, the strength of five different fixation techniques -anterior tension band wiring with K-wires, separate vertical wiring, headless compression screws with anterior tension band wiring, cannulated screws with tension band wiring and memory shape patellar fixator- for distal patellar fractures were compared. Forty calf knees were used for the biomechanical testing. Each specimen was pre-loaded with 10 N at 1 N/s. The distraction forces were applied consistently with the velocity of 5 mm/s. The ultimate load (N) and displacement (mm) values were recorded. The headless compression screw with anterior tension band wiring (656.9±167.9 N) and the cannulated screws with anterior tension band wiring (642.6±166.0 N) obtained significantly higher ultimate loading values compared to the other fixation methods (p<0.05). Fixation via cannulated screws with anterior tension band wiring techniques are more stabile than the patellar shape memory fixator and anterior K wire fixation.